|  |  | 

India Top Headlines

It does not judge experts to decide the suitability of economic policies: SC | India News


NEW DELHI: In what may be music to the ears of critics of the judiciary’s foray into the executive and legislative domains, the Supreme Court on Tuesday was sparing no words in ruling that judges and lawyers are not experts in examining suitability or the efficiency of the economy or the efficiency of the government. financial policy decisions and suggest alternatives.
The CV said that lawyers and judges do not normally have proficiency in these fields. “Economic and fiscal regulatory measures are a field in which judges must interfere with great caution since they are not experts on these issues,” he said.
These comments came from a bank of judges Ashok Bhushan, RS Reddy and MR Shah, who rejected requests to increase the scope of the economic packages announced last year by the Union government to provide relief to economic activities affected by the pandemic. .
In drafting the judgment, Judge Shah said: “What is best in the national economy and how and to what extent financial aid packages will be formulated, offered and implemented and will ultimately be offered, will be decided by the government and the RBI on help and advice from experts ”.
“These are exclusively from the central government province. Such matters do not normally attract the power of judicial review, ”said Judge Shah. The court said that what the court must examine is the legality of the policy and not the wisdom or soundness behind it.

Original source